44th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1978

The 44th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1978 is one of the most significant amendments in the history of the Indian Constitution. It was enacted to res

44th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1978 – A Detailed Analysis

The 44th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1978 is one of the most significant amendments in the history of the Indian Constitution. It was enacted to restore democracy, protect Fundamental Rights, and limit the powers of the Executive after the Emergency period (1975–1977) imposed by then-Prime Minister Indira Gandhi.

This amendment came as a response to the 42nd Constitutional Amendment Act, 1976, which was passed during the Emergency based on the recommendations of the Swaran Singh Committee. The 42nd Amendment, often called the “Mini-Constitution”, gave sweeping powers to the Parliament and the Executive, restricted Judicial Review, and curtailed Fundamental Rights.

When the Janata Party government came to power in 1977, led by Prime Minister Morarji Desai, it introduced the 44th Amendment Act to reverse many provisions of the 42nd Amendment and safeguard democratic principles.

In this detailed blog post, we will discuss the background, objectives, key provisions, significance, criticisms, and impact of the 44th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1978.

---

Background of the 44th Constitutional Amendment

During the Emergency period (1975–1977) declared under Article 352, civil liberties were suspended, the press was censored, and political dissent was suppressed. The 42nd Amendment, passed in 1976, concentrated power in the Parliament and Executive, weakened the Judiciary, and reduced individual freedoms.

When the Janata Party came into power in 1977, it aimed to restore the democratic framework of the Constitution. The government introduced the 44th Constitutional Amendment Bill in 1978, intending to:

• Restore Fundamental Rights

• Strengthen Judicial Review

• Limit the misuse of Emergency provisions

• Reestablish the balance of power between the Legislature, Executive, and Judiciary

The bill was passed by both Houses of Parliament and received the President’s assent on 30th April 1979.

---

Objectives of the 44th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1978

The main objectives of this amendment were:

1. To Restore Democracy

   • Reverse the authoritarian provisions introduced during the Emergency and revive citizens’ freedoms.

2. To Protect Fundamental Rights

   • Reinstate the supremacy of Fundamental Rights over Directive Principles of State Policy (DPSPs).

3. To Prevent Misuse of Emergency Powers

   • Make it difficult for the Executive to arbitrarily impose Emergency in the future.

4. To Strengthen the Judiciary

   • Restore the powers of the Supreme Court and High Courts to review laws and protect citizens’ rights.

5. To Reinforce Federalism

   • Reduce centralization of power and restore the autonomy of state governments.

---

Key Provisions of the 44th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1978

The amendment introduced several landmark changes in the Constitution to safeguard democracy and individual rights.

---

1. Restrictions on Proclamation of Emergency (Article 352)

• Before the 44th Amendment, the President could declare National Emergency on the advice of the Prime Minister.

• Now, a written recommendation of the entire Union Cabinet is required.

• Additionally, the grounds for Emergency were limited to “armed rebellion” instead of the vague term “internal disturbance” used earlier.

---

2. Parliamentary Approval for Emergency

• The amendment made it mandatory for both Houses of Parliament to approve Emergency within one month (earlier six months).

• To continue Emergency, approval is required every six months.

• If the Lok Sabha rejects the Emergency, it must be revoked immediately.

---

3. Protection of Fundamental Rights (Articles 20 & 21)

• During the Emergency declared under Article 352, rights under Article 20 (Protection in respect of conviction for offences) and Article 21 (Right to Life and Personal Liberty) cannot be suspended.

• This ensures that citizens cannot be unlawfully detained or deprived of life and liberty, even during Emergency.

---

4. Restoration of Fundamental Rights Over DPSPs

• The 42nd Amendment gave Directive Principles of State Policy precedence over Fundamental Rights.

• The 44th Amendment reversed this and reaffirmed the supremacy of Fundamental Rights.

---

5. Abolition of Right to Property as a Fundamental Right

• The right to property under Article 31 was removed from the list of Fundamental Rights.

• It was introduced as a legal right under Article 300A.

• This was done to allow the government to acquire private property for public purposes without facing complex legal challenges.

---

6. Safeguards for Press Freedom

• The 44th Amendment restored freedom of the press, which had been curtailed during the Emergency.

---

7. Restoration of Judicial Review

• The amendment reinstated the power of the Supreme Court and High Courts to review laws and constitutional amendments to ensure they do not violate Fundamental Rights.

---

8. Changes in Lok Sabha and State Assemblies Tenure

• The 42nd Amendment increased the tenure of the Lok Sabha and State Legislative Assemblies from 5 to 6 years.

• The 44th Amendment restored it to 5 years to ensure frequent elections and greater accountability.

---

9. Protection Against Arbitrary Dismissal of State Governments (Article 356)

• The amendment made it harder for the Union Government to misuse President’s Rule by requiring parliamentary approval.

---

Impact of the 44th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1978

The amendment had a transformative effect on Indian democracy:

1. Strengthened Democracy

• It restored the checks and balances between the Legislature, Executive, and Judiciary.

2. Safeguarded Civil Liberties

• By protecting Articles 20 and 21, the amendment ensured that basic rights cannot be suspended, even in Emergency.

3. Restricted Misuse of Emergency Powers

• The new safeguards made it difficult for any government to impose Emergency arbitrarily.

4. Empowered the Judiciary

• Restoring judicial review strengthened the independence of the courts and protected constitutional morality.

5. Rebalanced Centre-State Relations

• By restricting the misuse of Article 356, the amendment upheld the federal structure of the Constitution.

---

Criticism of the 44th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1978

Despite its positive contributions, the amendment faced criticism:

• Right to Property Downgraded: Removing it as a Fundamental Right affected individuals’ ability to challenge unlawful land acquisitions.

• Partial Rollback: Not all provisions of the 42nd Amendment were reversed, leaving some controversial changes intact.

• Implementation Issues: Though it strengthened constitutional safeguards, practical misuse of powers by governments has continued in some cases.

---

Significance of the 44th Amendment in Modern India

The 44th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1978 holds great relevance even today:

• It ensures that citizens’ fundamental freedoms remain protected, even during political crises.

• It established constitutional safeguards to prevent another Emergency-like situation.

• It reaffirmed the principle of limited government, ensuring that power remains accountable to the people.

---

Conclusion

The 44th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1978 was a turning point in India’s constitutional history. It reversed many provisions of the 42nd Amendment that had concentrated power in the Executive and undermined democratic institutions. By restoring judicial independence, strengthening Fundamental Rights, and restricting Emergency powers, the amendment ensured that citizens’ liberties and India’s democracy were safeguarded.

While it did not undo all the damage caused by the Emergency, the 44th Amendment reaffirmed the spirit of the Constitution and provided a robust framework to protect democracy, federalism, and civil liberties in India.

---

READ ALSO

1. 42nd Constitutional Amendment Act, 1976 – The Mini-Constitution Explained

2. Fundamental Rights vs Directive Principles – A Detailed Comparison

3. The Role of Judiciary During the Emergency (1975–1977)

4. Fundamental Duties in the Indian Constitution – Importance and Evolution

5. Swaran Singh Committee Report and Its Impact on the Constitution